I like the idea of the personal break if it has anything to do with stopping some sort of artificial staying online to ensure no attacks. However, if a person is genuinely playing the game trying to hold onto grog/gold for upgrades, training, etc, it's unfair to punish that person buy enforcing the 10 minute break in which time they've lost a good portion of their ill-gotten gains. One of the people in our guild has had it happen to her. She readily admits she's obsessed, she uses gems to buy outfits mostly so doesn't gem her recruiting. It is not uncommon for her to be online for 10 hours. Midoki, couldn't the Personal Break be tweaked so that the attacker still gets all rewards, the attacked loses the PR but gets the grog/gold reimbursed so there is no financial penalty? The reimbursement could apply only to attacks during a personal break, and the robotic software or whatever is being targeted still stays targeted. Most importantly, your most devoted fans of the game won't be turned against it.